Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Do not withhold good from those who deserve it when it is in your power to act. Proverbs 3:27

The Lord is my light and my salvation- whom shall I fear?
The Lord is the stronghold of my life- of whom shall I be afraid?

The one issue that attracted the attention of many in the last mandalam meeting was the Kuwait Episode. A perusal of the Questions & Answers printed and circulated among the Mandalam Members will prove this. Those questions were raised by:
1. Mr. Sajan Veloor of Dubai Mar Thoma Church(Qn. 6.II; Page: 5),
2. Mr. Shibu Oommen of Prayar Sehion (Qn.14.I; page: 10),
3. Mr. Samkumar G. of Pazhinjam St. Paul's (Qn. 20:II; page: 18),
4. Prof. Koshy Mathai of Othera St. Pauls (Qn. 24.III; Page: 22),
5. Prof. Dr. Alex Abraham Odikandathil (Qn. 31: III; Page: 28),
6. Rev. Koshy C.K. of Channappetta Bethany (Qn. 41. I; page: 37),
7. Mr. K.P. Philip of Kuriannur Mar Thoma Church( Qn. 47.II, page: 43), and
8. Mr. M.C. James of Vallamkulam St. Lukes (49.1, page: 44).

If 8 out of 49 were to seek answers to one single question, that's too many people and too big in terms of proportion and percentage.
If so vast a number had concern over this issue, it had to be of paramount importance and the Sabha leadership should have been upright and honest in their response.

But did we get any satisfactory answer to those questions enveloping such a grave matter? What are our rights and privileges as Mandalam members?

The Metropolitan told this asker that he does not want to talk about it as it is a matter of sub judice. Believing it, I withdrew my question but when I later found that he is evading questions, I got on my feet with a sub-question to another's but he said everything is done in order and claimed that the diocesean episcopa maintains a proper file for it, to which the concerned bishop nodded with grace. Then, waving the Kuwaitee brochure above my head, I asked it be put on the table when the Metropolitan said he has many copies of the same and that Kuwait people who are rich can afford to print such colorful notices, feigning(?) ignorance of the parliamentary procedure. Then we were told how the Kuwait marthomites sent a pentecostal emissary for compromise talk but how he refused to yield and threatened to take steps against Kuwait people to get them extridited from Kuwait for collecting money using Sabha's letter-head etc.- something that discounts the very decorum of the house. Since I did not have any further information on the subject, I had to leave the matter there but was tempted to think the reference to 'nanjool' and 'cultic movements' along with the statement, " ഈ സുഭിക്ഷത എന്നും നിലനില്‍ലക്കും എന്ന് വിചാരിക്കരുത്, സമൃദ്ധിയുടെ മേച്ചില്‍ സ്ഥലങ്ങളില്‍ നിന്നുകൊണ്ട് സഭയുടെ ദര്‍ശനതെയും ശിക്ഷനത്തെയും അവഹെളിക്കുന്നവര്‍ തങ്ങളുടെ ജീവിതത്തില്‍ വന്‍ വീഴ്ചകള്‍ അനുഭവിക്കുന്നു എന്നതിന് നമ്മുടെ തലമുറയില്‍ തന്നെ ധാരാളം ദ്രിഷ്ടാന്തങ്ങള്‍ ഉണ്ട്" in the presidential address was aimed at Kuwaitee Marthomites- a cheap and hollow threat resorted to by ecclesiastes from time immemorial for emotional and psychological upper hand over their opponents; an exercise in futility and of little significance and of zero effect, anymore.

Sabha, as mentioned above, has a vision? discipline? a BIG joke, it is!
For me, this is by and large, a privilege issue.. which needs to be settled... once and for all.

Now, there is this Big New Question in Kuwait:
Why did the three Marthomite priests in Kuwait boycott the Viewing/ Homage Service of a deceased Marthomite?
Were they expressly told/ ordered to keep away?
Who do the priests owe allegiance to- their superiors, Mar Thoma Church or a Higher Power? Who pays them for their services in their capacity as priests?

Please re-read my subject line:
Do not withhold good from those who deserve it when it is in your power to act. Proverbs 3:27

And what are the allegations surrounding the stone-laying of the brand-new Pandanad Immanuel MT Church by the Suffragan Metropolitan? Defy the law of the land, including but not limited to, the encroachment of public property?

I am eager to know...

Thank you,
Love,
Adv. Alex Abraham Odikandathil

5 comments:

  1. Waiting for What Next

    response e-mailed by Mr. Sajan)

    Dear Prof. Alex , you might have a taste of the shadowy things that is happening in the corridors of church power center but we ordinary marthomites like me and may be 99% of marthomites had no clue , at least on its gravity and depth, till the end of 2010. But now we are befuddled at discovering our achens, bishops and marthoma church more and more every day. If you really know the true facts as what happened in Kuwait Church , you will not believe it could ever happen anywhere. Don’t believe me or any one who say , ask the church leadership , if they have nerve to send 2-3 mandalam members to Kuwait to know the truth , they will never do it. The whole marthomite community thru their representatives of 1000 mandalam members were fooled by giving totally untrue facts on questions raised. Let some of them come and see the reality of Kuwait Marthoma Church, even if you are a hardcore supporter of Methran and even if you are blessed with the highest level of serenity, you will feel to devour those people who are untiringly propagating and perpetuating the fabricated stories to defend their masters who have proved in letter and spirit to be wolves in sheep’s attire. Inside these beautiful redolent sepulchers, is full of filth and muck. The decay is much beyond our wildest imaginations.
    These leaders and their goons in Kuwait were dreaming people will fall in their line in 2 months 3 months but now it is 9 months and people are resolute never to bow down before the mafia’s tactics. Births, weddings , quirbana, baptism and deaths , they thought they could trounce us with each of these events , but God is failings their dreams , because the One who lead us is no one else , the All Powerful and All knowing, All Mighty God is our leader , He cares in all our needs at each step. It is no surprise when he threatened in mandalam ‘’ to take steps against Kuwait people to get them extridited from Kuwait for collecting money using Sabha's letter-head etc’’.- something that discounts the very decorum of the house… he is doing all at full force .. day one to crush the people who were keeping him on their palms and shoulders and always accorded a red-carpet welcome. As someone wrote today ‘’In the stubbornness of their hearts they are least concern of the murders they do of their flock. They become blind in their greed for fame or power, their pride and their lust for things of this world. They should understand when Jesus said it was better for them to tie a large rock around their neck and jump in the sea than harm His (spiritual) little ones’’

    We are unwavering, ‘’ Though the fig tree does not bud and there are no grapes on the vines, though the olive crop fails and the fields produce no food, though there are no sheep in the pen and no cattle in the stalls,yet I will rejoice in the LORD, I will be joyful in God my Savior. The Sovereign LORD is my strength; he makes my feet like the feet of a deer, he enables me to tread on the heights.’’
    (Habakuk 3 : 17to 19)
    God is in control and He is watching everything.
    Sajan

    ReplyDelete
  2. My reply to Sajan in Marthoma Group

    Dear Sajan,

    (My reply vide marthomachurch@yahoogroups.com)

    I'm seeing the injustice and high-handedness of the church for too long..
    even argued in favor of our bishops getting married- to avoid untoward incidents..
    and voiced my opinion strongly against donations in our colleges to improve the quality of the teachers and the taught...
    that was in the Mandalam... way back in 1984... and defended the rights of the laity at all costs.
    I know what you are talking about...
    Lets hope for the best, though at times it seems like hoping against hope.
    Thanks and stay in touch, bye now.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Prof. Dr. Alex Abraham Odikandathil to marthomachurch in response to K.M. John's alias, Snowbreeze) derogatory remarks.

    The reason I'm reluctant to answer Slowbreeze is due to his name and nature...
    a breeze is slow, a slow breeze is double slow..
    so in psychiatric parlance, you must be intellectually challenged, Mr/ Mrs/ Eunuch/ Trans-gendered Slowbreeze
    - mental retardation or autism?
    Your level of cognitive functioning is not of much significance to me though I noticed your enthusiasm to read into things that were not there: hearing and seeing things that are not there- delusional?
    We know that there are people who have surnames, last names or family names and those names come down the family, ie. through one's father.
    So, I have a problem talking to somebody who doesn't have a family name.
    You call me brother?
    That form of address is common among African- American Muslims; in a few christian denominations as well.
    I know you can be a priest at worst; a rogue at best. Either way, you are no rival to me.
    And either way, I am unable to engage you...
    And don't expect me to answer your quibble.
    Bye now.

    ReplyDelete
  4. In response to Philip C. Mathew's (owner of Presidency Hotel in Ekm?) derogatory comments, Prof. Dr. Alex A Odikandathil writes:

    You admit those are 'old and new marthoma public secrets'..
    then why do you want me to go after evidence?
    Any group is not a fact-finding body having judicial powers.
    I told you what I heard and if you are so curious, why don't you follow them up?
    thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Response from samathewtvm@yahoo.com on Sept 22nd, 2011.

    Dear Brother
    Wish you all success to be a mandalam member/council member of marthoma sabha. Your advice is absolutely correct. we should accept all decisions taken by metro polita whether it is wrong/correct. Then only we will be good for him and get benifit from him. See now metropolita and his council gave printed answers to the questions related with Kuwait Marthoma Church.
    They said all marthomites in Kuwait are the members of Marthoma church - it is a fact - But why our achens there didnot attent the funeral service. I am sorry - we cannot think like that because we should protect the interest of our sabha leaders.

    We dont want to know what is the reaction of the people there and why they are continuing with the same worship. We should give good propoganda against them, because they are not obaying our marthoma metro polita as he is our god. We should enquire whether they are using our emblem or worship book there, to continue same worship - so we should do maximum effort to make them out of our great sabha
    .
    Mar Paulose and mar Iraneous are our leaders. Mar paulose represent congress party and Iraneous represent - BJP and CPM. So we are in safe side.The party will protect us in India and congress units in Kuwait will lookafter the church matters in Kuwait.

    But there is a question - Who is in CHRIST's side, Who will follow Jesus, Who will work for him, Congress, BJP or CPM ?

    Remember one day Jesus will enter the church as what he did in Jarusalem church during his tenure.

    Dear Brother if you are a real christian(not marthomite)-
    please ask the church leadership

    1) WHY YOU GAVE WRONG/MISLEADING INFORMATION ABOUT KUWAIT MARTHOMA CHURCH IN PRINTED FORM TO THE MANDALAM MEMBERS.
    2) ASK THE LEADERSHIP TO SEND 2 INDEPENDENT MEMBERS AMONG YOU TO KUWAIT AND SEE WHAT IS HAPPENING THERE.

    Dear, don't allow any one - who ever it is- to fool us- there is a new saying

    "MANDALANGANGALE MANDARAKKAN ANUVADIKKARUTHU" .

    "DON'T ALLOW TO MAKE FOOL OUR MANDALAM MEMBERS"

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete